What is an independent pharmacy review?
A specialist assessment by an external pharmacist, conducted specifically for insurance purposes, to identify medication-related risks and optimisation opportunities.
Published: 3 April 2026 | Updated: 3 April 2026
What is an Independent Pharmacy Review?
An independent pharmacy review is a medication assessment conducted by an accredited pharmacist who has no clinical treating relationship with the claimant. You refer for an independent pharmacy review to obtain objective expert opinion on medication management within an insurance claim context.
Unlike HMRs or RMMRs, which are government-funded services, you typically refer for independent reviews directly to answer specific clinical questions about medication therapy, identify risks, or determine whether current medication management is appropriate and cost-effective.
When Do You Use an Independent Pharmacy Review?
You would typically refer for an independent pharmacy review when:
- You have specific concerns about medication safety or appropriateness
- Polypharmacy is driving significant costs and you need expert assessment of deprescribing opportunities
- There is dispute about medication necessity or dosing between medical practitioners and your claims team
- The claimant does not meet criteria for HMR or RMMR but you still need expert medication assessment
- You need an expert opinion on whether proposed medications are evidence-based and cost-justified
- You are managing medication-related adverse events and need to determine causation and future management
- The claimant is in a jurisdiction where HMR or RMMR is not readily available
Independent Review vs Government-Funded Reviews
| Feature | Independent Review | HMR | RMMR |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who initiates | Insurance company | GP referral | Aged care facility |
| Funding | Insurer-funded | Government subsidised | Government subsidised |
| Clinical independence | Complete, no prior relationships | External to GP practice | External to facility |
| GP involvement | Limited, mainly for information | Direct consultation | Direct consultation |
| Report audience | Insurer focused | GP and claimant focused | Facility and practitioners |
| Scope | Insurance-specific questions | General medication optimisation | Individual and facility-level |
The Independent Review Process
Step 1: Scope Definition
You define the specific questions the pharmacist should address. Are you asking about medication appropriateness, cost-effectiveness, deprescribing opportunities, or safety concerns? Clear scope ensures the review addresses your specific needs.
Step 2: Information Gathering
The pharmacist requests medical records, medication lists, pathology results, and other clinical information needed to conduct the review. They may request information directly from you, the claimant, or the claimant's treating doctors.
Step 3: Clinical Analysis
The pharmacist conducts a comprehensive assessment against current clinical guidelines, evidence, and best practice. They identify medication-related problems, assess appropriateness of current therapy, and evaluate opportunities for optimisation.
Step 4: Report Development
The pharmacist prepares a detailed expert report addressing your specific questions, providing clinical rationale, and making actionable recommendations. The report is structured for insurance claims use, not clinical implementation.
Step 5: Consultation and Advice
You may discuss the findings with the pharmacist to ensure you understand the clinical basis for recommendations and how to implement them within your claims management strategy.
Content of an Independent Pharmacy Review Report
An independent review report typically includes:
- Summary of the claimant's medical history and current medications
- Assessment against clinical guidelines and evidence
- Identification of medication-related problems and risks
- Analysis of medication appropriateness and cost-effectiveness
- Specific recommendations for medication changes or deprescribing
- Clinical rationale for each recommendation
- Implementation recommendations and monitoring suggestions
- Response to specific questions posed in the referral
- Expert opinion on contested medication management issues
Pharmacy Review in Complex Claims
Independent pharmacy reviews are particularly valuable in complex or high-cost claims. For example:
- A claimant on 15 medications with unclear indications for several drugs. Review identifies deprescribing opportunities that reduce both cost and adverse effects.
- Dispute between treating GP and rehabilitation provider about whether specific medications are evidence-based. Independent review provides objective expert opinion.
- Claimant with medication-related hospitalisation. Review determines whether the adverse event was preventable and what changes should be made.
- Request for expensive specialist medication. Review assesses whether current standard therapy is adequate or whether escalation is justified.
Cost and Accessibility
Independent reviews are funded directly by the insurer, so you control timing, scope, and the specific pharmacist involved. This flexibility makes independent reviews accessible regardless of the claimant's age, location, or number of medications. You can refer for an independent review when HMR or RMMR would not be appropriate or available.
Timelines
Independent reviews can typically be conducted relatively quickly, often within 1-2 weeks if information is readily available. This makes them suitable for time-sensitive claims decisions.
Need expert independent assessment of medication management?
IMM specialises in independent pharmacy reviews for insurance claims. Our pharmacists deliver expert, objective assessment tailored to your specific claims management questions, with clear, actionable recommendations. We work across AU and NZ and understand the insurance claims environment.
Request a Medication Review
